Description
Circa 1930, 116 Colon Avenue is a captivating blend of historic charm and modern enhancements set against the scenic backdrop of Fort Mose Historic Park. Motivated sellers have now priced the property well below recent appraisal of $395,000. This compound offers not only a beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom furnished main residence but also a 600-square-foot detached furnished studio garage! The main home spans 1,451 square feet and exudes the warmth and nostalgia of Old Florida while thoughtfully updated for today’s lifestyle. At the front of the home, a cheerful Florida room welcomes you with natural light and a relaxing atmosphere. Inside, a cozy living room leads into the dining room, which connects seamlessly to a bright, well-appointed kitchen featuring ample cabinetry, a built-in breakfast nook, large pantry/storage room and fresh sunlight. Down a quiet hallway, the bedrooms are comfortably positioned for privacy. Enhancing the property’s appeal is the detached studio garage—an impressive 600-square-foot space complete with a full bathroom, laundry area, kitchenette, and flexible open layout, perfect for guests, creative pursuits, or rental potential. Whether you envision a guest house, private office, or multi-generational space, this flexible addition is ready to meet your needs. Out back, enjoy tranquil mornings or evening breezes from the rear porch, perfect for outdoor lounging or casual entertaining. The fenced property offers plenty of room for gardening, a pool or storage in the detached shed. Coveted rear access from the neighboring road—ideal for added convenience and functionality. Short term rentals can be done here if you're looking for additional income. Located just a short bike ride from Historic Downtown St. Augustine’s vibrant shops, restaurants, and cafes—and only minutes from the beach/boat ramps—this home is a rare opportunity to own a piece of Florida’s history with the freedom and comfort of modern living. Offered with a 1 year home warranty. Come experience the charm of 116 Colon Avenue—where some history, heart, and home come together.
-
3BEDS
-
N/AACRES
-
2BATHS
-
01/2 BATHS
-
1,451SQFT
-
$254$/SQFT
School Information
Description
Circa 1930, 116 Colon Avenue is a captivating blend of historic charm and modern enhancements set against the scenic backdrop of Fort Mose Historic Park. Motivated sellers have now priced the property well below recent appraisal of $395,000. This compound offers not only a beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom furnished main residence but also a 600-square-foot detached furnished studio garage! The main home spans 1,451 square feet and exudes the warmth and nostalgia of Old Florida while thoughtfully updated for today’s lifestyle. At the front of the home, a cheerful Florida room welcomes you with natural light and a relaxing atmosphere. Inside, a cozy living room leads into the dining room, which connects seamlessly to a bright, well-appointed kitchen featuring ample cabinetry, a built-in breakfast nook, large pantry/storage room and fresh sunlight. Down a quiet hallway, the bedrooms are comfortably positioned for privacy. Enhancing the property’s appeal is the detached studio garage—an impressive 600-square-foot space complete with a full bathroom, laundry area, kitchenette, and flexible open layout, perfect for guests, creative pursuits, or rental potential. Whether you envision a guest house, private office, or multi-generational space, this flexible addition is ready to meet your needs. Out back, enjoy tranquil mornings or evening breezes from the rear porch, perfect for outdoor lounging or casual entertaining. The fenced property offers plenty of room for gardening, a pool or storage in the detached shed. Coveted rear access from the neighboring road—ideal for added convenience and functionality. Short term rentals can be done here if you're looking for additional income. Located just a short bike ride from Historic Downtown St. Augustine’s vibrant shops, restaurants, and cafes—and only minutes from the beach/boat ramps—this home is a rare opportunity to own a piece of Florida’s history with the freedom and comfort of modern living. Offered with a 1 year home warranty. Come experience the charm of 116 Colon Avenue—where some history, heart, and home come together.
© 2026 St. Augustine & St. Johns County Board of Realtors. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is believed to be accurate but not guaranteed by the MLS or Sunshine Realty & Appraisal Services, LLC. Data last updated 2026-05-17T10:30:50.59.